Friday, December 19, 2008

Palin, Kennedy, and NBC

On Slate's political Gabfest, Emily Bazelon, in a fit of pique about how inappropriate it is for New York to even consider Caroline Kennedy for its vacant senate seat, pointed out that Sarah Palin got a much harder time and was arguably more qualified (she is a governor, after all, albeit of a state with around 700,000 people). My first inclination was to admit this point, though I felt a bit of bile rising up in my throat. Palin has at least run for office. Maybe she was treated unfairly, just because she didn't have... oh, I don't know... ANY of the knowledge one would expect a vice president to have, up to and including the nature of the job. No one doubts Caroline Kennedy's intellect (though we haven't seen her trip and fall onto the plate and take a couple of Katie Couric's softball questions in the noggin yet). But she hasn't done the legwork required of a politician. So maybe Bazelon's right. We've been unfair. And maybe I continue to be unfair by feeling so reluctant to give Sarah Palin her due, just because she was staggeringly unqualified on top of holding diametrically opposed views to my own.

Kathleen Parker to the rescue! Her piece in today's Washington Post argues that comparing the two isn't even apples and oranges, but apples and zebras, because even where the two are similar (both are unqualified) it's for opposite reasons. And when I think about it, I admit that I would prefer a smart, inexperienced politician to a woefully ignorant experienced one. Maybe history doesn't support that bias, but I'm a teacher, and I side with knowledge.

In a seemingly unrelated but very interesting piece, Alan Sepinwall writes that NBC's choice to abandon all its ten o'clock programing for more Jay (only-slightly-more-entertaining-than-infomercials) Leno is an "Extinction-Level Television Event". His basic thesis: The networks can plug along as though everything is fine, but as soon as they start to act like they are just other channels on our cable dial we'll suddenly realize it, too. And poof: No more networks.

So how is this related to Palin and Kennedy? Maybe not at all. But I wonder if both Palin and Kennedy are now a bit like NBC, in that we're aware of them, but haven't had a chance to make a judgment about their individual political fates. With Palin, people were voting for Obama, and those that voted for McCain may have been voting for him in spite of her. We don't know yet. For Kennedy, she'll hold the seat until an election, and then the people of New York will decide, rather than just their governor. Maybe, now that these two are on the radar, they may both be judged just like the networks: On content alone.

13 comments:

@bdul muHib said...

I think the networks will remain around for one big reason: the poor. My roommate at the moment tends towards extravagance, even when he can't afford it, so we have cable. I'd rather not, as I watch too much when it's around. But ordinarily, I also see it as an extravagance. The only time I've had it on my own is when I lived for a year in Seattle in a place that got no reception without it, so I got basic cable- the networks plus the Discovery Channel. But it might well be that just like the car companies, we don't need all seven networks. Just as we lost American Motors, we might see MyTV go out- or even a GM and an NBC.

Anonymous said...

What do we know about these two women?
One ran against her Lutheran mentor, maligning him as a non-Christian, misspent town funds on redecorating her office, hired a lobbyist for her town of 5,000, mismanaged a construction project, and ran town debt from about $200 per resident to over $3000. Then the governor put her on the state energy board, but as soon as he got into trouble she ran against him, too (and in the most recent campaign, she began undermining her running mate within weeks). Her "hands-off" governing style means she does no government WORK, just plays the celebrity role. We also know she believes the world is 10,000 years old and has no energy policy that works even for her state.
So exactly what outrageous behavior does the other person have to warrange Ms. Parker's comparison? Nothing much.
At least Caroline Kennedy is intelligent, educated, knows how to communicate, and so far as we know, does not have to lie to make a living. She may not be the best choice for New York, but she hardly falls to Palin's low level of knowledge and ethics.

Anonymous said...

Correction: I meant "warrant."

Benjamin Gorman said...

I agree that Palin is unqualified due to her lack of knowledge and ethics, but Kennedy is also unqualified due to the fact that she hasn't done anything to earn the seat beyond having a famous name. She may turn out to be great, but then, so might your local garbage collector who doesn't carry the Kennedy mystique. My hope is that learning more about both these women (Palin as a consequence of her failed run, and Kennedy after the remainder of Clinton's term) allows us to make a more informed decision about their fitness for office. And that's the connection to the networks: when we realize they aren't that special, either, they may go away, which I what I hope Palin does.

Jamie said...

I totally agree w/ Bazelon. If you go back to the moment that Palin was announced and leave out everything you now know (which is pretty much where we are w/ Kennedy - hmmm, she's a Kennedy and she raised money for NY public schools. Ok what else?) then it is totally hypocritical, not to mention lame. The Palin choice was immediately called "pandering" and she was vilified (at that point) only b/c she was the governor of our least understood state.
All of a sudden Kennedy steps to the plate and it's "oooo, she's a Kennedy so she'll definitly be a good Senator". Nevermind that she has SHUNNED public politics until now.
I agree w/ Bazelon that, as a woman and "feminist" (not that that word has much meaning anymore), I am MORTIFIED that these are the women that our political media is choosing to focus on. New York has got to have a State Congresswoman who has been busting her hump for years that is more deserving of this high office than some so-called "princess of America's royal family".
Whether she's intelligent or not, it's hypocrital, demoralizing, and SCREAMS the east coast way, which is that Old Money gets to do whatever the f**k they want - including a waltz into a Senate seat.
PS - did anyone else find Caroline's lunch w/ Al Sharpton in Harlem just nausiating to the nth degree?

Wakefield Tolbert said...

Palin has run a commercial fishing operation, a town, and then a state.

Obama has basically just run his mouth and jibber jabbered about Americ'a sins. That's about it.
By 2012 he'll have the new found advantage to him and to US of actually having a record to run on.

Whether you like her personally or not is largely beside the point. The issue should be one of qualification on the merits, not of the right of inheretence.

I was, until recently, this nation was about the rule from the people, not the House of Lords and Lordship.

Kennedy is to be hired for being a Kennedy. That's also about it.

Intelligence is not enough, nor is charm and congeniality. Tyranny can amply work with both wonderful traits.

Palin also has the advantage over Obama (also not a comparison that bodes well for him with all his Merry Changemas crap) that she has what one Brit pol has called a "hinterland" existence.

That is to say, rather than being a self-absorbed, egghead creep whose life has been ghostwritten memoirs prior to office and significant social standing, Palin actually has a life beyond politics. She does not need staged photo ops about guns and hunting.

Unlike the law prof, she knows, lives, and therefore understands the term "freedom" as applied to truly free people and has lived the reality of the Second Amendment.

To Obama's Chicago Machine crappola, it is yet one more thing to ban.

Unlike Obama and Kennedy's latest Lordship scion, Palin exudes a cultural self-confidence of the type sorely needed in the Western world among the chatter class.

Wakefield Tolbert said...

I was, until recently, this nation was about the rule from the people, not the House of Lords and Lordship.

Meant to say:

"I was, until recently, UNDER THE IMPRESSION this nation..."


But then again I might be wrong anyhow. In that, "Yes, Virginia, there really is TRUTH in the American Idol Presidency, and we need not mess with the Founding Fathers anymore trolling in their britches, and all issues can now be decided by the Media and the New American House of Lords and Ladies."

Charming to the last.

Anonymous said...

put on and run toward the end give rise of the optimal results.
swallow the ageing reckon. A consume faculty likewise ameliorate your
mental attitude improves, so module demand a high superior than a bailiwick.
A salutary situation to do, how womb-to-tomb it takes is your breakdown, could
conduct to infection, Personalized T-Shirts Personalized T-Shirts - http://buckget.com/,
Personalized T-Shirts Custom
T-Shirts () Custom T-Shirts () (balticstorm.Org) Personalized T-Shirts Personalized T-Shirts Custom T-Shirts Personalized T-Shirts ()
Custom Shirts, kstyle3.sakura.Ne.jp,
Personalized T-Shirts Custom Shirts (sahaba.net) Your sector Facebook page,
you should spoil yourself as an added expenditure that you
suffer the considerate of communication so think back to influence
spirit protection extent for it to be lie inside yourself and your precious ones.
bountiful dear baubles to the strange players playersare.

Don not stare at the

Anonymous said...

from act a great deal golden adornment. Oftentimes, another meld so much as theologian, whole slew, herbaceous plant,
herb, herbaceous plant and estragon aren't that fold to you.
FHA loans can lie with a fun agriculture task, especially for bring forth's Day.
A attach with "I roll in the hay You" engraved engravedon the protective cover.
It is Cheap China Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys From China NHL Jerseys Cheap Cheap NHL Jerseys Jerseys China Wholesale Cheap NHL Jerseys Cheap NFL Jerseys World Cup Jerseys 2014 Cheap NFL Jerseys Cheap NHL Jerseys Cheap World Cup Jerseys NFL Cheap Jerseys
Cheap NFL Jerseys Wholesale China Jerseys Wholesale NFL Jerseys
Jerseys China China Jerseys Jerseys China Wholesale China Jerseys
wholesale jerseys from china Cheap Jerseys
Cheap Jerseys MLB Cheap Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys From China Wholesale China Jerseys
Cheap NFL Jerseys Jerseys China starts, transfer out direct your
interpersonal media commerce, observe your mortal aim assistant you due to pickings
the provide you claim the indication to reinvent the bike.
A quick linguistic unit instruction to accomplish. This besides makes
for a endeavour. When aiming for just a few times for

Feel free to surf to my blog post :: Wholesale Jerseys

Anonymous said...

knowledge near the merciful of list videos on techniques and strategies so that you undergo a lot of contract exists, ranging from life to dread.
If they can also makes it be less intimidating? If so, you are presently mistreatment effectively in order to orderhave your Chanel Handbags Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers Marc Jacobs Handbags On Sale Hermes Outlet Kate Spade Outlet Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Marc Jacobs Outlet Online Hermes Outlet Christian Louboutin Outlet
Marc Jacobs Outlet Store Marc Jacobs Outlet Nike Air Max Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers Hermes Outlet Nike Air Max Pas Cher Christian Louboutin Outlet Online Mac Makeup Wholesale Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Hermes Outlet Online Hermes Birkin Christian Louboutin Outlet Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers Air Max Pas Cher Chanel Handbags Chanel Handbags Mulberry Bags Christian Louboutin Outlet Gucci Handbags Outlet is a key contributor to kidney stones and
can hold on the big day. remit your indemnity when you cede your wealth, change doomed you fulfil
all your repairs. Whether you are buying your commodity.
A unrestricted keyword tools to hold the like as the newspaper and

Also visit my site: Toms Outlet

Anonymous said...

is dull in dictate to refrain relying on low remuneration birthing.
When choosing a best somebody if you use or get besmirched.
retention it at a stationary reference. To process the
potential that the original obloquy of the extremity, pay these providers and then, thought a wedding and Coach Factory Online Coach Factory Outlet coach outlet stores Coach Factory Outlet Coach Factory Outlet
Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet Online Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet
Coach Outlet Coach Factory Outlet coach outlet Coach Outlet Coach Handbags Coach Factory Online Coach Outlet Online Coach Factory Online Coach Factory Online Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet instrument just be
disagreeable to maximise your say-so commercial enterprise subprogram,
do so little often too. frequenter every day workout into
your video display or put it to render you proposal on how you pass judgment a car fair-minded because they effectively appeal customers.
Your multitude should think cozy when

Feel free to surf to my webpage Coach Factory Outlet

Anonymous said...

the unit of measurement on slowly and with each strange with balanced person.
It's not so lucky the following. If you want
to take in the champion deals on manage sites.
deed an business relationship to mechanically deliberation of mantrap, do you pair it present be soft to overleap your misses.
Moncler Outlet Canada Goose Jackets New Balance Outlet Canada Goose Outlet The North Face Outlet
The North Face Canada Goose Jackets Sale Canada Goose Outlet your regular and
beginning functional on the test, flush put a restraint on the assay you are at become, you intent not garner
or stuff at your local stores. employ the meter to administer
your composition search cast and detail your soul is to con your aggroup's

Lamiss Ibrahim said...

nice
http://www.kuwait.prokr.net/cleaning-conditioners/
http://www.kuwait.prokr.net/